Opinion: School Times Need Change

December 7, 2017

With the controversy surrounding MISD’s 7:25 start time, a committee has formed to discuss changing the time to later in the morning.

School Day Should Start Later

Teens across America experience sleep deprivation. Recent studies show teenagers learn better later in the day, therefore the school board needs to make school times later.

Classes begin at 7:25 a.m. in the Mansfield high schools and most buses pick up students from their bus stop around or before 6 a.m. This means students wake up at about 5 a.m. School ends at 2:55 p.m. Moving the start time back, even by an hour, would place students’ instruction time in the prime hours for learning and allow more sleep for students.

According to the National Sleep Foundation, teens need a minimum of nine and a quarter hours of sleep each night to function at their best. Studies also show that only 15 percent of teens reported sleeping eight and a half hours on school nights, however, most students go to sleep about 11 p.m. Giving students an extra hour of sleep in the morning would increase a teenager’s total sleep hours.

As a result of the loss of sleep, studies also showed students may experience: memory and cognitive impairment, inability to pay attention, shortened mental sharpness, uncreative problem solving, overall mood and motivation, and the potential of accumulating more pimples. According to the National Sleep Foundation and WebMD, these effects could lead to other disorderly consequences like narcolepsy, insomnia, restless legs syndrome or sleep apnea. Lack of alertness could lead to accidents and affect plans later in the day. Also, students need sleep in order to succeed in the classroom. If they suffer from sleep deprivation, paying attention and showing effort becomes more difficult. An hour extra of sleep per night multiplied by 20 days a month results in a significant sleep increase therefore resulting in better mental concentration on school work.

Not only is more sleep required, the study shows a teenager’s body functions better later in the day. On the current schedule, MISD students fight a natural biological force. Melatonin releases later in the day for teens causing students to be awake in the evening. Even if a student gets 10 hours of sleep, students will be naturally sleepy in early the hours because of their biological clock. Adjusting the school start time benefits a student’s natural learning habits.

A school district in Minnesota moved start times from 7:25 a.m. to 8:30 and saw increased attendance, more alertness, less depression and better grades overall.

In addition to homework, some teens also have jobs. Students, however, could utilize their time before school, instead of working late into the night, to finish up assignments if school started later. This would prepare students more thoroughly for the day, because they would be able to complete homework and therefore, be less tired. Better preparation and sleep may increase alertness, attentiveness and concentration. Gradually, grades would improve, while also boosting the school’s time investment in their students.

If school times remain the same, students will continue to feel tired and drained throughout the day. Early start times and lack of sleep can cause grades to fall.

Bus schedules are one reason for earlier school start times. Moving the start time in all schools in MISD would not affect the daily bus schedule.

Therefore, grades would improve and effective student learning and improve teen’s lives if the start time was pushed back. The school board should change school starting times for later in the morning.

 

Please visit The Ultimate Guide to Teen Sleep for more information.

About the Contributor
Photo of Phillip Smith
Phillip Smith, Sports Editor

Hi, my name is Phillip Smith and I'm the Sports Editor for The Rider Online. I have been in journalism for three years, I'm on varsity basketball, and...

View 5 Comments

School Times Should Not Change

Some say that later start times will correct countless problems of student awareness in school, but the issues with the later start time outweigh the pros.

Sports and activities such as football, basketball, volleyball, band and theater all have practice after school for about three hours a day, and with a later start time comes later practice. If we push school back an hour to 8:25 a.m., then the time we get out of school will be an hour later (3:55 p.m.), causing practice to be pushed back. For example an organization that originally has practice from 3:00 p.m. until 6:00 p.m. would not finish until close to 7:00 p.m. The students that still have homework, on average takes at least an hour and a half to do along with other necessities to take care of such as dinner, showering and basic socialization. With all of this, students do not go to bed until around 11 p.m on a good night and still only gives students eight hours of sleep. Pushing the start time back two hours will have an even more drastic effect.

Some students involved in activities also work outside of school. Pushing the school day back even something as small as an hour can affect how much time after school a student has to fit in homework, after school activities, work, socialization and other life events.

With pushing high school hours back also affects the other school levels’ start time. The school day times are staggered because of bus scheduling. Students who ride the bus now may not get home until around 4 p.m because of the bus route, so with the later start time, they would not get home until around 5 p.m. The time change’s impact would fall on students in other levels of schools, because those that now get out of school at 4 p.m would not get out until 5 p.m and not home until 6 p.m.

Teachers have lives and want to go home to their families. Some usually offer tutoring after school for students that need extra help, retake tests or get makeup work. They also stay later to grade papers, making lesson plans and work. Pushing back school times will make teachers get home later depending on where they live.

Moving the start time makes less time for productivity outside of school. Students will likely use the time before school to sleep rather than do homework. In the winter, the time changes, the days get shorter and it starts to get dark outside by 5:30 p.m. Oversleeping and tardiness would still persist as an issue as students continue to stay up late and not get enough sleep.

Therefore, students benefit more from an earlier start time more than a later start time because of the greater amount of time for productivity.

About the Writer
Photo of Jazmine Necessary
Jazmine Necessary, Editor-In-Chief

After romantic candlelit dinners and long walks on the beach, I enjoy writing for this website and making lame jokes.

Leave a Comment
Donate to The Rider Online | Legacy HS Student Media
$800
$5000
Contributed
Our Goal