Two Different Worlds

English Language Learners (ELL) Learn English Through Core Classes

During 6th period, Rosalinda Sanchez, 11, reads an English dictionary in the hallway at Mansfield Legacy High School on Jan. 22. The English Language Learners (ELL) learn English through core classes.

Ryland Mallett

During 6th period, Rosalinda Sanchez, 11, reads an English dictionary in the hallway at Mansfield Legacy High School on Jan. 22. The English Language Learners (ELL) learn English through core classes.

Original Interview Audio In Spanish

Her nerves consumed her body as she walked into the school with her aunt, neither knowing a single word in English. She had one thing on her mind ‘how can I make her understand?’. For junior Rosalinda Sanchez, it seemed like ELL (English Language Learners) teacher Michelle Alamudun came in as her saving grace to translate for her and her aunt at the front desk. Not knowing English had become her first stepping stone.

She didn’t understand it then, but Sanchez had just taken the first step into a better future. 

“Al principio fue muy difícil por el idioma ya que no entendía mayoría de la parte de las cosas que trataban de decirme, pero ya ahorita estoy bien,” Sanchez said. 

“In the beginning, it was very difficult because of the language since I didn’t understand the majority of the things that they tried to tell me, but right now I’m doing alright,” Sanchez said.

Sanchez left her home in Acapulco Guerrero, Mexico, to live with her aunt and uncle in Mansfield. Sanchez was born in America, but lived her entire life in Mexico because of her parents’ jobs. When she first moved to America, Sanchez felt depressed and alone because she had a very tight relationship with her mom and missed her. Her parents could not travel with her to the U.S. due to work complications back in Mexico that would not allow them to stay in the U.S, so she lived with her aunt and uncle during her stay. 

“Si estoy un poco deprimida porque siempre estoy con mi mamá, pero está bien porque sé que ella quiso que yo viniera acá para esforzarme y ser alguien en la vida,” Sanchez said. “Y pues por eso quiero echarle ganas y estar bien con ella.”

“Yes. I’m a little depressed because I’m always with my mom, but it’s okay because I know that she wanted me to come over here to strive and be someone in life,” Sanchez said. “And because of that I want to try my hardest and be okay with her” 

Sanchez, one out of many ELL immigrant born students in the U.S. but still considered foreign in the system since she does not speak english. According to Colorin Colorado the majority of ELLs enrolled in public school systems were born in the United States.

“Al principio tenía miedo de lo que la gente decía porque la mayoría del inglés lo entendía y la gente pensaba que yo no hablaba inglés y no le entendía y decían cosas malas y yo las entendía,” Sanchez said. “Y pues al principio me sentía mal porque decía cómo pueden hacer así decían ‘porque estás aquí’ y ‘está mexicana’ y yo le decía que no que yo era de aquí.” 

“In the beginning I was scared of what other people said because I understood the majority of english and people thought that I didn’t speak english. I felt bad because I said to myself, how can they be like that they said ‘why are you here’ and ‘this Mexican’ and I would say no, I’m from here.”  

Sophomore Abimael Gonzalez found himself in a similar situation because of the challenges the language brought to them.

“Cómo no se el idioma no quiero hablarlo todavía por vergüenza. Como si no sabes unas cosas y que lo digas mal,” Gonzalez said. “Pero con amigos así cuando hablo con ellos en inglés si nos reímos de que no sabemos decir por qué vamos aprendiendo.” 

“Like I don’t know the language I don’t want to speak it out of embarrassment. Like if you don’t know some things and you say them wrong,” Gonzalez said. “But with my friends, when I’m just talking with them in english we do laugh about not knowing how to say things because we’re learning,”

 Gonzalez, an ELL student born in Fort Worth, Texas, came from Jalisco, Mexico, with his family of six because of his father’s job-related issues. Gonzalez said learning English felt like a plus to their current situation that can benefit him in his future. Although their temporary stay in the U.S. won’t last very long, he remains focused on school. 

“Ahorita estoy enfocado en acabar la prepa no creo estudiar en la universidad nada más acabó la prepa y empezar un negocio,” Gonzalez said. “Si lo puedo abrir sería donde sea más fácil siendo aquí (United States) o en México, pero ahorita sí estoy enfocado en acabar la preparatoria.” 

“Right now I’m focused on finishing high school I don’t think I’ll study at university level I’ll just finish high school and start a business,” Gonzalez said. “If I can start a business it would be where it’s easiest whether it be here or in Mexico, but right now I’m focused on finishing high school.” 

Gonzalez, one of 71.5 percent of ELL students who graduate from high school, compared with the overall graduation rate of 88.3%. To Ms. Alamudun, getting students to surpass the system’s expectations such as average test scores, low grades, and more remains one of her goals every year.

“So ELL is just simply a place where they can get comfortable learning the language, comfortable understanding what the teacher is requiring on them, and understand that they’re not going to get penalized because English is not your first language,” Ms. Alamudun said. “That’s what it’s supposed to do and in theory, it works.”

However, like every system, Ms. Alamudun must face the reality of what happens to her students inside and outside the classroom.

“I’m very much aware as an American citizen that we need everybody to be able to do every different job, but I don’t want ELL students to just be limited to this job, or this skill, or this level. I want them to understand it. You can go beyond me, you can go beyond the principle. You don’t let language be a barrier. You let it be a stepping stone,” Ms. Alamudun said. 

For Sanchez, not knowing English inside the classroom and outside of school affected her just as much outside the classroom. She had fears of the barrier that stood between the Americanized society and her Mexican roots. 

“Más que nada el choque cultural cómo crecí en México tengo diferente cultura y temía que dijera algo que no fuera del agrado de otra persona y hubiera ahí un problema,” Sanchez said. “Pero pues no me avergüenzo de tener raíces mexicanas por qué me enorgullece.” 

“More than anything the cultural crash like I grew up in Mexico I have different culture and I was afraid of saying something that someone else didn’t appreciate and then have a problem,” “But I’m not embarrassed of having Mexican roots because they fill me with pride.”  

The ELL classroom as described by Ms. Alamudun, a place where students can be themselves, a place where they can listen to any type of music, a place where they can pray for one another and a place of serenity for the students to go to and be successful. As described by Colorin Colorado it must be a class that can allow their transitions to flow smoothly as they can experience mood changes, anxiety and shock. Most, if not all, ELLs will go through the stages of Cultural Accommodation.

“A pesar de que mis otros maestros no hablan español hacen lo posible para que entienda los temas y eso de verdad fue sorprendente,” Sanchez said. “Cuando yo llegué aquí porque no esperaba eso esperaba que me mandarán a un rincón o así pero no fueron muy amables.” 

“Even though my other teachers don’t speak Spanish they do the most so that I can understand the lessons and that was truly surprising when I got here,” Sanchez said. “I didn’t expect that I expected them to send me to a corner or for them to be hostile.” 

Sanchez only hopes for Americans to change their ways of viewing foreign or immigrant students as time progresses. 

“Qué amén a las personas tal y como son y que en vez de juzgarlas las apoyen porque si están aquí es por algo y es porque quieren aprender la cultura de aquí y saber todo de aquí,” Sanchez said. 

“To love people just how they are and that instead of judging them they should support them because if they’re here it’s for a reason  and it’s because they want to learn about this culture and know everything about here,” Sanchez said.